• wisekwai
  • ranking : Nation Staff
  • created : 2007-08-30
  • entry : 230
  • visitors : 91552
  • votes : 27
  • send msg :
Wise Kwai's Bangkok Cinema Scene
What's playing in Bangkok cinemas?
Permalink : http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/wisekwai
Friday , October 12 , 2007
Ladda: Moviegoers in Thailand are uneducated
Posted by wisekwai , Reader : 690 , 23:59:54   | Category : culture   Thai film   Censorship and ratings  
Print



"Uneducated."

This is what a government official thinks of moviegoers in Thailand.

"They're not intellectuals — that's why we need ratings," Ladda Tangsupachai, 58, head of the Cultural Surveillance Department at the Ministry of Culture, is quoted as saying in a recent article in Time magazine.

The US-based news mag has a recap of the fight over Thailand's proposed new motion picture ratings system.

The battle over the proposed ratings system intensified in April, after the Board of Censors told Apichatpong Weerasethakul to cut four scenes from his critically acclaimed film, Syndromes and a Century, before he could release the film for limited screenings at two Bangkok cinemas.

Apichatpong refused, saying he'd rather cancel the screenings. However, the Board of Censors still confiscated his film, fearing that the offending images of doctors drinking whisky, a doctor getting an erection in his trousers whilst kissing his girlfriend, a monk playing a guitar and a pair of monks playing with a flying saucer, might somehow be viewed by "uneducated" moviegoers.

"Nobody goes to see films by Apichatpong," Ladda tells Time. "Thai people want to see comedy. We like a laugh."

So, then what would have been the harm in releasing Syndromes uncut, then, if nobody was going to see it?

The proposed ratings law, which is actually even more restrictive than the 1930 Censorship Code still in effect, is coming up for debate in the National Legislative Assembly.

An even bigger debate might be the view of cinema in Thailand - whether it can ever be considered art, or is purely entertainment.

But I don't suppose that's anything the "uneducated" masses could ever consider.


Read comment

comment 10
khun_k date : 12/02/2008 time : 17.42

Banning a movie here in Thailand is better than censoring it. I paid to see the original movie, they way it was made for us to enjoy. If they want to censor it then, they should pay us to see what they think is appropriate for us to watch.
comment 9
catch22 date : 21/10/2007 time : 00.56
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/catch22

TomFin (3) Were the cigarettes blurred out??
comment 8
klinsong date : 18/10/2007 time : 00.04
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/klinsong
-kai

Most people will accept unbias rating system. Properly use it will be good for Thailand, and improve Thais creativities.

Most people will be aganist censorship as we have today. It is so bad to the point that "big" studio in Thailand censor themselves to make the gov institution happy. Have you ever see a movie where a corrupted police get away with corruption?

We are killing our own creativities in our young people, hence, killing our own future.

Why do you think some big Thai corporations had to hire foreign consultant to teach our upper management "INNOVATION".
comment 7
Poomjai date : 16/10/2007 time : 14.29
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/poomjai

Cutlural Surveillance Department. That really says it all. Did anyone hear of the Ministry of Vice and the Promotion of Virtue?
comment 6
GGrass date : 15/10/2007 time : 08.32
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

i went to watch 'The Kingdom' last friday. it was good movie, good soundtrack... good action, definitely.

there was a 1/2 full of theater, and i'm sure in other theaters, the audience turnout were quite similar.

so, in Ladda's words, we were all 'uneducated' (rai karn suek sa) mass, just looking for silly laughs and jokes. i should have known, if i wanted to have some silly laugh and jokes, i should have gone to her house and see her well-educated kids watch movies... that way, i get my laughs, but i don't get called 'uneducated'.
comment 5
wisekwai date : 14/10/2007 time : 04.22
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/wisekwai

The censorship of films in Thailand is never applied consistently.

For Thai films, the big studios work hand-in-hand with the censors, and they seem to have a pretty good idea of what they can get away with.

Independent filmmakers like Apitchatpong come under more scrutiny because they aren't part of that network of cronyism. And, I think both the industry and the censors ganged up on Apitchatpong, to teach him a lesson about going outside the system and becoming so darn successful internationally.

For foreign films, Hollywood releases tend to come under scrutiny - 300 was censored here, as was The Departed. But other films slip through untouched.

With Tom Finn's example of the French film (The Witnesses, by chance?), he's right - the cops on the Censorship Board probably fell asleep, or didn't feel like sitting through some French film and gave it a pass without looking at it.
comment 4
veen date : 13/10/2007 time : 18.35
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/veen

Ladda's remark is a good script for a movie itself. You're right her latter remark (of no one wanna see Syndrome) seems to contradict the previous remark.


If I have to choose a group to be "educated", my priority would be Ladda's agency and the likes at Culture ministry.

Anywhere else, Joe (Apichat) can sue the ministry for seizing his film copy. This is so amazing to happen in the cyberspace era.

As for rating. Ladda also gets it wrong (or she intentionally wants to). Many filmmakers do agree with rating but the ministry and those who draft the new law has come up with the worst any filmmaker could imagine: They want both rating and censorship altogether. I've studied the detailed draft and it is so scary that if the bill passes, we'll surely go to the Stone Age.

Yes, Ladda is right for one. We like "a laugh" and her remark really makes us laugh with tears. LOL

comment 3
TomFin date : 13/10/2007 time : 11.05
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/justconsiderations

I am opposed to censorship of almostany kind.

I am frustrated by the lack of quality movies in Bangkok. ButI was a bit amused by a French film I recently saw. It had nudity that was not cut or covered. This included male frontal nudity

Maybe the censors fell asleep watching a French movie.
comment 2
happy date : 13/10/2007 time : 09.28
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/history

thank you for bringing it up. Sometimes I have the impression that Thailand is trying to take over China with restrictions, control and censorship. This is not avoiding harm to the people, it is avoiding people to become adult and democratically educated.

If the country wants to protect their people, it would be better to develop a social insurance system with free health care, worker unions and better free education so the "uneducated masses" become educated.
comment 1
Pondering date : 13/10/2007 time : 05.36
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/pondering

Wow...that is really pathetic!
close comment or only member can comment
"If you are not member, please register to comment.
It take only a few steps."


  |