Stupidest poll ever |
A few days ago a poll was
conducted by ABAC, asking “people” who
they most preferred as the new Police chief. The sample—most of them or actually the highest number—chose Gen.
Jongrak, followed by the current contenders. This was a surprise to many and was reported extensively upon by the
media, without comment as they were puzzled themselves about the result. It’s a disgrace for ABAC to
have such a polling team in its payroll. This poll has driven ABAC a notch down
in its general academic ranking, and undermines its credibility as a top regional
university which it is striving for. 1. Why should ABAC ask this kind of question to
the people, presumably the man in the street. What use is the answer? It certainly can’t be acted on by the
government. No government can rule by
taking into account such polls, especially badly conceived ones. 2. And who was the sample and
what logic was used to choose this kind of sample to ask this kind of
question? The answer would be of some
value if the sample consisted of those knowledgeable in police affairs, its
politics and history. Then, any
consensus or any divisions reported would be of a representation of opinion of “wise
people” or the “players”, which would be useful to decision-makers. 3. Then, in this kind of
important issue, you’ve got to ask why the respondent chose the answer he/she
did. Not hard at all to tag another question,
closed or open. Why didn’t they
ask? The answer we got now is useless
without knowing the reason. Incomplete,
as if eating half a hamburger. The reason why another such
question was not asked was probably financial, and too much time involved in
processing, and time is money. 4. The poll asked a sample of people who I
wouldn’t go so far as to say not qualified, but who probably have only a
superficial knowledge of this important issue. So what does the public gain from knowing the answer? Nothing—because the methodology was badly
conceived. Truly a waste of paper and media
space. Polling in |
| โดย stalingrad |
| วันที่ เสาร์ กันยายน 2552 |
พิมพ์หน้านี้
|