• lin
  • ranking : Nation Staff
  • email : achara_d@nationgroup.com
  • created : 2007-07-07
  • entry : 23
  • visitors : 42731
  • votes : 39
  • send msg :
general
business insights, general
Permalink : http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/lin
Thursday , July 22 , 2010
Rebuilding the nation: Part II
Posted by lin , Reader : 2928 , 00:05:24  
Print


I’m now totally convinced that Thais forget things easily. Two months have passed, but there is nothing whatsoever to hold anybody accountable for the fatalities of nearly 100 men and the injuries of over 1,000. It was as if they were not existent, and thus their departure went unnoticed.


I’m also convinced that it is hard to uproot social division, as rather than the deaths of Thais, many have a better memory of the fire that burnt some buildings in the inner Bangkok – the fire that united some Thais in a cleaning scheme and leads to the controversial TV commercial “Thailand, we apologise”.


I have a strong doubt how capable the reform committee would be in addressing the problem at its root.


Realising the deep division, people in the business circle for the first time realise that they could not stay idly. A joint movement is being formed, to address key problems that they believe to have caused this disaster. Matter-of-factly, they hit the heart of the problem, with the joint effort to eradicate corruption.


A leading businessman admitted that the bureaucratic system offers corruption opportunities. Without clear timeframes of licensing, for example, government officials can hold on applications. If you want it fast, you have to pay. For people who do not have money, they resort to help, mostly from rich relatives or powerful politicians. This could be returned by lifetime supports to the relatives, ie free labour at parties, or endless votes for the politicians. Yes, in Thai society where seniority and power rules, this nurtures the patronage system. This would go away only when fairness is granted to all, through a fair and transparent system.


Corruption is at every level. A private school which relies on the government’s financial supports doctored the number of students for higher funds, with approval from the government’s representatives who are offered presents and some tips. Police officers twist the rules to take bribes from motorists, charging them of not attaching the registration document on the windshield. Indeed, the Land Transport Department then allows all not to attach it, but they have to make it available for inspection.


Being a girl from a remote district in Khon Kaen, I knew some interesting development. I will share it with you here.


Even when I was young, Chumphae district was remembered as a dusty town, being a major junction for the shipment from Muang district and provinces beyond to the Northern routes, and vice versa. As a busy town, there were business opportunities. Like in the movie shot decades ago, there were Chao Phor who were nobody than influential figures with extensive business or a large base of supporters. These figures befriended with police and their businesses ran smoothly. On special occasions like New Year, presents were given in return.


Laymen needed to befriend with these influential figures, for their own protection from bully or for some financial supports when needy.


As the number of those benefiting from the patronage system grew, the influential figures ended up being politicians or vote buyers for politicians. Being a politician meant you can award someone a government contract, for something in return. And being close to politicians, you were entitled to some protection and supports. This only strengthened their positions and the story goes on and on.


The situation improves largely now. The hospital is being enlarged and better services are on offer. Roads are expanded in all directions. But influential figures remain in power, thanks to their established status. It is known that in a village, who are politicians’ representatives. When election comes, it is known before hand who would win more votes from the village. Challenges could mean death as everybody knows each other, which explains why killings are rampant in the election season.


Politicians themselves need to work hard in nurturing the relationship. When their men’s sons reach the ordination age, they become sponsors. When their men’s parents die, they finance the funeral service. When their men’s relatives are caught by police for some violation, they broker for a release.


In the national level, that explains why politicians want to be ministers, who are in charge of budget allocation. Budgets could be allocated to their constituencies, to benefit their men and to win supports from villagers. Eventually, a new road is extended to a remote village, thanks to the man villagers voted for. That also explains why politicians can’t stop being greedy. Their wealth must be strengthened to ensure the power continuity. Yes, the power is sweet.


Given this scenario, ones may see no possibility in breaking the vicious cycle. I’m not that pessimistic, though. After all the chaos earlier this year, I think it’s time for a change and all should lend a hand if they don’t want to witness more fatalities or more burning of leading shopping centres.

To be continued in Part III.

 


Read comment

comment 29
FelixQui date : 24/09/2010 time : 20.10
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/FelixQui

And proving that the draconian and barbaric forces of suppression, denial and ignorance continue to rule in Thailand, this latest from the Nation:
http://www.nationmultimedia.com/home/Prachatai-editor-arrested-30138684.html
comment 28
FelixQui date : 24/09/2010 time : 20.10
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/FelixQui

Excellent piece in today's Nation by the consistently courageous and incisive Pravit Rojanaphruk.

"It may be time to take off the bilindfold" is at http://www.nationmultimedia.com/home/2010/09/23/politics/It-may-be-time-to-take-off-the-bilindfold-30138569.html

The CRES suppressors of free speech and knowledge for Thai citizens must have gone into apoplexy.
comment 27
Ian date : 26/07/2010 time : 17.38
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

Not only have I not burnt bridges I have created new ones in HK, Malaysia and the Philippines. My life has never been carved in stone
comment 26
noonin date : 25/07/2010 time : 20.13
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/noonin

Comment 25,
There were no bridges to burn!
comment 25
Ian date : 24/07/2010 time : 22.28
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

janus, why do you persist in telling me what I already know, why do you think that unlike you I have not burnt my bridges behind me.?
comment 24
janus date : 24/07/2010 time : 18.20
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/mi58

Just a warning Ian!
The powers that be in your village are pawns and you are nothing in Thai eyes!
Same in British eyes, old man has Thai girlfriend, so what!
comment 23
Ian date : 24/07/2010 time : 03.10
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

janus, 22. I can't be bothered to get into another puerile argument with you, so you are perfectly correct, bang on the nail, a perfect bullseye, a paragon of human analysis and judgment. Happy now me old cock robin?
comment 22
noonin date : 23/07/2010 time : 23.36
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/noonin

Ian,
A low profile!
You are kidding, everyone knows who you are and that is what you wanted!
Thailand is not some backwater!
You have checked me out and the Thai whoever's have checked you out!!
comment 21
Ian date : 23/07/2010 time : 23.02
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

Janus, 16. You are so wrong, I am not arrogant, I know I have no chance against the powers that be. I keep a low profile,I just operate at a very local level and at infrequent intervals. I don't shove,I nudge,I am happy to let others take the credit, which is important to Thais, particularly at election times.
comment 20
Plaadip date : 23/07/2010 time : 22.07
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

arryaaaa, sorry, I mean C18 in c19.
comment 19
Plaadip date : 23/07/2010 time : 22.03
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

c19, you don't have to post two.

We are in 2010! Why not a Xmas song!!
comment 18
janus date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.48
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/mi58


Now for some music!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txMQYExIhcg
comment 17
janus date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.48
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/mi58


Now for some music!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txMQYExIhcg
comment 16
janus date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.45
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/mi58

Comment 15, Ian,

I agree, but you are able to choose to stay or go, I am not!
If you had a wife and child here then I might forgive you for your arrogance!
Do you really think you, yes you, can defend yourself against the powers that be here?
No way, only a Thai can!
comment 15
Ian date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.33
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

Janus, "This is also the problem, you are now part of the process!"

Indeed so, but with one major difference, I cannot be bribed. What I achieve might benefit me, but it also benefits the village. Before I started paying the police, there were no patrols in my village, now there are.
comment 14
Plaadip date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.28
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

c12, I mean the easy one for any journalists or politicians to answer. Abhist is saying the same thing ,always, in terms of that easy one.
comment 13
noonin date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.27
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/noonin

Comment 11,

It is not about changing values , it is accepting the values that exist and modifying them to be part of the present.
You cannot change Thailand, it is!
Thailand can and has adapted through the centuries; once it was not Thailand, it was Siam, before that Khmer or something, it is of no importance whatever the national name is/ was.!
Thailand is a small place on Earth, with special geographic properties and a people of a genetic make up. Culture is the dynamic, not to be lost through a small failure at a small juncture in its history!
comment 12
Plaadip date : 23/07/2010 time : 21.23
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

c11, loooooog time solution. The easy one.
comment 11
lin date : 23/07/2010 time : 20.54
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/lin

c5 and 8, i'm not as naive as our prime minister, who believe that just preaching would help change everything. certainly, education is not a panacea. and when i said changing values, it's not going to happen overnight and this needs cooperation from all parts of society.
comment 10
janus date : 23/07/2010 time : 18.41
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/mi58

Quote Ian, comment 1

"But it upset the village boss as he had been trying for months to get this done. Now he and I have learnt to work together "

This is also the problem, you are now part of the process!

In Thailand it is necessary to play along, you need to report ( post Thaksin, before not enforced) to Immigration every 90 days and renew your visa each year; cross the wrong people and you know what will happen! Just as the humble Thai do.
You have previously stated that you pay for local police protection, now you admit to negotiating with the local headman; who is using who?
comment 9
janus date : 23/07/2010 time : 11.58
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/mi58

Is Thai culture tolerant or indifferent?
The daily exposure to such obvious corruption has certainly made me indifferent; that's how it is here!

Read today's editorial in the BP.
Same old same old!

EDITORIAL

What are our generals up to?
Published: 23/07/2010 at 12:00 AM
Newspaper section: News

By the very nature of its work, the Office of the Auditor-General is probably not well-versed in military affairs and may not presume to have the last word when it comes to what weapons or war machinery the country should be buying. Still, because of the office's qualification as a prudential examiner of the state's financial and monetary affairs, its advice given to the Defence Ministry when the latter first planned to purchase armoured personnel carriers (APCs) from the Ukraine three years ago, should still be heeded, now that the ministry is seeking to buy another batch.


Three years ago in 2007, the army through the Defence Ministry ordered 96 APCs worth billions of baht from the Ukraine. The deal was proposed by then army chief Gen Sonthi Boonyaratkalin, who led the Council of National Security in staging a coup against Thaksin Shinawatra. The OAG at that time cautioned against the procurement proposal as it claimed the Ukrainian company, which won the bid for this purchase, failed to submit the necessary documents on time. The OAG found the APCs' tyres and thin plating made the vehicles unsuitable for combat use.

As it turned out, the Thai army has to date not yet received any of the 96 APCs it ordered, because the manufacturer at first had problems securing engines for the vehicles. Once it managed to find a supplier willing to sell the engines, it got stuck with assembling the vehicles. So three years have passed and the Thai army has yet to take delivery of the APCs.

Considering the dismal history of the Ukrainian deal, it is an unpleasant surprise that the army is still pushing ahead with a plan to buy an additional 121 APCs from the same source.

It is understandable that as the current army chief Gen Anupong Paojinda is set to retire this year, he would like to spend the remaining budget on a cache' that would enhance the capabilities of the Thai army. Defence Permanent Secretary Apichart Penkitti echoed this rationale when he told reporters that the ministry had already approved the army's request for the APCs and that money should not be a concern since the army has enough funds left in this year's budget to cover the cost of the purchase.

Both Gen Anupong and Gen Apichart should know, however, that it is not the amount of money or the staying within budget that is the main concern here. What matters here is whether the army and the Defence Ministry are spending taxpayers' money prudently and wisely - or not. Does ordering more goods from a manufacturer who has failed to deliver on the first purchase sound sensible, let alone smart?

News reports stated that the army chief will seek Cabinet approval for a 4.6-billion-baht budget to purchase the APCs next week. Considering past procurement scandals which the army still cannot shake off - be it the bogus bomb detecting GT 200 device, or the 300-million-baht reconnaissance airship which refuses to fly up to the required height - the army surely should reconsider this latest proposal.

To argue that it is entitled to spend the money within its budget is not good enough. It has to show the public that it has considered its procurement carefully and chosen to spend only on those goods which are worthy and can be proven to add to the might of the Thai army. To ask the Cabinet to agree to what seems like a random shopping list, purportedly because it believes it has some leftover money to spend, is not a responsible act. Moreover, is this conduct becoming of generals who are in charge of the Thai defence forces?


comment 8
Plaadip date : 22/07/2010 time : 22.52
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

All the politics can do is to change the law, regulation, policy to induce a positive change in society. The type of argument "we should change our value, our culture first" tends to end up in a tautology : "We should change our value system and culture to change our value system and culuture."

I hope your part three will not be like that. Cheers.
comment 7
FelixQui date : 22/07/2010 time : 21.44
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/FelixQui

I meant abolish all laws that make freely chosen prostitution ILlegal. It's very dangerous revising a sentence halfway through and then not reviewing before hitting "Send Comment".
comment 6
FelixQui date : 22/07/2010 time : 21.42
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/FelixQui

It would help a lot if the numerous laws that seem directly intended to encourage corruption were summarily revoked.
Abolishing all laws making freely chosen prostitution fully legal would be a big hit at the pockets of those who sponsor corruption, as would legalising gambling. Those laws are not only unjust, but they directly breed and incite the climate of corruption, which then spreads to every other area of Thai society, making it rotten all the way through to the great detriment of the Thai people.

I cannot help but think that those who favour such laws are on the whole on the take and oppose legalisation because it severely cut back their corruption profits.

Once that start were made, the fight could be extended using the freed up police resources to prosecute corruption elsewhere.
comment 5
Plaadip date : 22/07/2010 time : 21.01
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

I understood!!. You want to talk about "education". What a valuable point!! Bye, bye.
comment 4
Plaadip date : 22/07/2010 time : 20.57
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

c3,.....but.... how can you change it?
comment 3
lin date : 22/07/2010 time : 20.35
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/lin

yes, Ian. that's the point. suggestions to end this vicious cycle will be on part III.
C2: just change to the electoral system won't help, as long as Thai culture and Thai value stays intact.
comment 2
Plaadip date : 22/07/2010 time : 15.19
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/55555

Why don't you advocate to introduce a full-fledged propotional representative system? The electral system could decrease the power of local bosses considerably.
comment 1
Ian date : 22/07/2010 time : 02.47
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

Lin, the problem seems to be that there is a chain of command, from the village headman right up to the PM. When I first moved into my village I created problems, I jumped this chain, there was a problem with the street drains, had been for months. Instead of going to the village boss I went straight to the amphoe boss, two steps higher up the chain, the workmen turned up the next day. This seemed normal to me, it is what I would do in England. But it upset the village boss as he had been trying for months to get this done. Now he and I have learnt to work together
The point I am making is that if people can communicate directly, via workshops etc, with local MPs and senior civil servants, then there is far less opportunity for corruption. You don't have to bribe people as you move up the chain.
Comment

  "If you are not member, please register to comment.
It take only a few steps."


  |  
name :  
email :  
website :  
comment :  
   
   

back top

<< July 2010 >>
s m t w t f s
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31