• GGrass
  • ranking : Classic Member
  • email : Greenestofgreengrass@gmail.com
  • created : 2007-06-13
  • entry : 224
  • visitors : 53854
  • votes : 72
  • send msg :
GGrass / anything goes...
just about anything goes...
Permalink : http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass
Thursday , June 26 , 2008
Punishing my son with a cane...
Posted by GGrass , Reader : 275 , 11:41:09  
Print


Broom stick was always the worst, while cloth hanger was the softest. But most of the time, the beating was done with a broom stick because it was always within my mom's reach. Or may be she wore it by her side.

I don't blame her for breaking all those broom sticks against my legs... I was a handful. But at the time of getting hit on my legs with sweeshing broom stick, I really hated my mom. I guess what my mom lacked was the kind of explaining that was required to not make me wonder why the hell I was getting hit on my legs with the broom stick. And what good it could possibly do for me.

Today, my mom will disagree that she didn't explain enough. She'll say it was I who didn't pay attention while she was lecturing. Well, that's true too.

So not to make my son fall asleep while I was lecturing, I made it short and precise. In fact, I practiced my speach over and over again in my head before I did the real thing.

I figure, if I could make my son understand clearly what he had done wrong, and why it was necessary to hit him with the cane, which by the way was made from a hollow metal stick of a laundry hanger, I thought he would learn something and not be a naughty boy again.

You see, the teacher from the kindergarden had told my wife, that my son had hit other kids in the classroom. She said whenever my son was in bad mood, he would punch and kick anyone who came near him.

It wasn't the first time... The first time, my wife said she reprimanded Sey gravely, and Sey had understood and repented. So I didn't interfere. But this time, I figure I had to do something because obviously my wife's lecturing didn't work. After long and hard thoughts, I decided it was time to teach my son the traditional way... with a stick.

I came home, and after washing my face and my hands, I brought the cane and put it on the bed, where Sey was sitting with smiling face. I sat him down in front of me, and asked him,

"Did you hit your friends at school today?"

"Yes. I did." Sey answered with a smile.

I was glad my son had admitted so easily. At least he wasn't a liar.

"Why did you hit your friends?"

Sey didn't answer that, but the smile had disappeared from his face.

"Were your friends hurt?"

"Yes, they were hurt..."

"How would you like it if  they hit you and you were hurt?"

"I don't want to be hurt..."

"Then you shouldn't hurt others, should you?"

"..."

By now, my son was almost crying... I was trying my best not to burst out laughing though.

"Sey, I will hit you with this cane, so you will know what it means to be hurt."

"No daddy... I won't hit my friends again... don't hit me..."

"Sorry, Sey. When you do something, there's always consequences which follows your action. In this case, the consequence is this. You can do whatever you want, but you have to be responsible for your actions. Put your hands out like this."

I grabbed his tiny hands and opened his palm, facing up. He shrugged and tried to hug me. I grabbed him firmly and sat him down, insisting he hold out his hand by himself. I didn't want to force him to accept the hit. I wanted him to accept it by himself.

And I was so happy when my son put out his small hands... He was a MAN!

'Brave boy!'

I shouted in my head. And firmly, I struck three times on his open palms.

SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!

Sey didn't even flinch. He really was a brave one.

After the last hit, I asked him,

"Did it hurt?"

"No."

LOL.... I laughed in my head. May be he was trying to put on a brave show. May be it really didn't hurt at all. But I had to make sure, so I told him,

"This time, I'm only hitting you softly. But if the teachers tell me you hit your friends again, "

I stopped in the middle of the scentence, and I hit hard on the pillow with the stick, making a loud bang. This time Sey did flinch a bit.

"I'll hit you like this. Understood?"

"Understood. Can we play now?"

So there goes my FIRST experience with punishing my son by hitting... I don't know if it was the right thing to do, but at least my son was OK with it.

Now I really hope this had taught him a lesson and he will not hit his friends in the kindergarden. Let's see if it worked...


Read comment

comment 22
Manhunt date : 01/07/2008 time : 13.27

GGrass - I kinda agree with Ian that talking helps better than spanking, after reeling back to how I was being brought up without canes. "Face the wall" was my father's way whilst my mum just stared hard at me in the public with her witch-like eyes. OMG, i could piss in my pants by looking at her eye balls. It worked & I'm such a good boy. See!
comment 21
GGrass date : 01/07/2008 time : 09.57
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

Ian: I didn't smack him in public. I did it at home.
comment 20
Ian date : 30/06/2008 time : 17.01
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

GG, in the home a smack is not needed because one has the time to reason with a child or use alternative methods like sending to bed. In a public situation, these options are not available, for example at a cinema if the child keeps talking all the time, or is badly behaved in a restaurant.
So I smack to get silence, then discuss it with him when I get home, just as you did.
comment 19
GGrass date : 30/06/2008 time : 10.34
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

Pan: Because it leaves such a long lasting impression, it is useful.

Us, the parents, just have to know how to hit our children so that the lasting impression are 'good' ones.
comment 18
GGrass date : 30/06/2008 time : 10.27
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

pan: It's true, physical smack will leave some impression on young kids' minds FOREVER.

But the impression doesn't have to be bad ones... There are ways to do it so that the memories will not be so bad... actually even good.
comment 17
panalwayscute date : 29/06/2008 time : 21.06
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/panalwayscute

GG,Manhunt,Catch-I don't hit my kid because I was hit by my aunt when I was young. I played with matches which made her think I want to burn the house.......It made me grow up not liking her until today unfortunately. She was never married, so whenever she got pissed from work, I got the smack.....That's why I realised that physical pain inflicted to a kid is emotionally affected........forever....
comment 16
catch22 date : 29/06/2008 time : 15.37
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/catch22

Pan - simply has to refuse to give her daughter any of her scrumpuous looking meals.

Now that's what I call cruelty!!
comment 15
GGrass date : 28/06/2008 time : 12.04
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

Ian: With all due respect,

I would have thought that corporal punishment should be done at home, not in public... In fact, hitting your kids in public would be a very wrong thing to do.

I would never hit my kids in public.
comment 14
Manhunt date : 27/06/2008 time : 21.18

Ian - I was often being told that kids in the West behaved better than Asian kids. I am not sure how true this is but you've been in Asia for long enough to give your judgement. Again I am not sure if this has anything to do with the hot weather again.
comment 13
Ian date : 27/06/2008 time : 18.26
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

GG, only rarely, usually in a public situation where immediate results are needed. In the home words have always been more effective than smacks.
comment 12
GGrass date : 27/06/2008 time : 09.15
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

Ian: Did you ever resort to hitting your children?
comment 11
Ian date : 26/06/2008 time : 23.04
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/anterian36

With kids psychological warfare is always more effective than corporal punishment But as a parent corporal punishment takes less effort an is more satisfying
comment 10
Manhunt date : 26/06/2008 time : 20.59

Sulasno - Bluetooth on both ears? Pan could nag like a deep frying wok in action

I've seen too many spoilt rotten kids everywhere but spanking them hard should be definitely good. I hope that Sey would grow up tough like his Papa........who is fearless
comment 9
Sulasno date : 26/06/2008 time : 20.41
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/sulasno

c8

wat cotton buds?

haven't you heard of bluetooth headphones ? :-)
comment 8
Manhunt date : 26/06/2008 time : 17.49

Pan - What a great mummy you are not having to use canes! Your daughter wore cotton buds each time you nagged? I would rather be like brave Sey and get spanked instead of hearing my mum nag. It could run into hours and days! OMG!
comment 7
GGrass date : 26/06/2008 time : 15.43
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

Pan: You're lucky you never had to hit your daughter.

I think being a good parent is knowing when to hit and when not to hit. God help me...
comment 6
GGrass date : 26/06/2008 time : 14.33
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/GGrass

It wasn't easy for me to hit my son like that...

But I feel I would be neglecting my duty as a father if I didn't hit him in this circumstance.

In Korea, in the past, the parents will give bundles of wooden canes to the teachers for them to use on their children. The teachers who use up the wooden cane the fastest are considered the best teachers.
comment 5
panalwayscute date : 26/06/2008 time : 14.11
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/panalwayscute

I never hit my kid. It was always in words in punishing her. She would feel really bad about it and apologise and promised not to do it again. It's worked.
comment 4
Seven date : 26/06/2008 time : 14.10
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/truethai
Sao Grabrong Hian

Little innocent children can be like little devils sometimes. If talking to them does not help they need to be punished.
comment 3
Manhunt date : 26/06/2008 time : 14.03

Sulasno - Surprise! You also ate chillies like me Our moms could be sisters. My dad would send me to stand by the wall for 1 hour when naughty. That's how I mastered the art of sleeping on 2 legs today
comment 2
Sulasno date : 26/06/2008 time : 12.56
http://blog.nationmultimedia.com/sulasno

Manhunt,

are you sure that our Moms are not acquainted? :-)

in addition to putting chillies when I used "bad wwords" I have to kneel on my knees and pull my ears when I did something wrong (which was most of the times) ( I was rebellious when I was a young boy)

Reflecting back, I think my Mom made me a disciplined young man and hence cannot tolerated any nonsense :-)

Reminds me of the time when I was making lunch and my little sweetheart (she's my favorite grandniece) picked up granite and threw them at my car. Her grandaunt called out to me and I told her to come here and open the palm of the hand which threw the granite. Threatening to beat the palm she ran off crying to the house :-)
After making lunch, her grandaunt brought her out and told me to give her a hug and forgive her. She hugged mr, crying and said that she love me. :-)
Seriously how could I have hit her. She's a devil. She knows that I loved her a lot. Even her parents dare not scold or hit her when I am around and she would have complained to me and I would reprimard her parents. She's really a devil :-)

On her birthdays she would called me to remind me and wants a Mickey Mouse cake :-)
comment 1
Manhunt date : 26/06/2008 time : 12.09

Like father, like son making 2 happiest clowns

My mum would put small red chillies into my mouth because I used vulgar words on my elders. Now I am still bitching....where's mum?
Comment

  "If you are not member, please register to comment.
It take only a few steps."


  |  
name :  
email :  
website :  
comment :  
   
   

back top

<< June 2008 >>
s m t w t f s
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30